Best Membership Website Builders 2019

Who do you turn to when you need a Membership Website Builder? There are plenty of options to choose from, but which one is right for you? How do you know that you’ll get the necessary tools to help your members have the best web presence they can possibly have? Well, our team here at Comparakeet has put together a top ten list of Membership Website Builders that know their stuff. We’ve put these companies through the wringer to find the very best quality  membership website builders available today!

Wild Apricot1st9.0 out of 10$40.00 Per Month

Wild Apricot Review

Designed for clubs, non-profits, and the like, Wild Apricot is a great website builder for managing members, events, donations, e-mails and much more.Full Wild Apricot Review »
Wix2nd9.9 out of 10$7.00 Per Month

Wix Review

Wix is an amazing website builder with over 500+ beautiful templates, extreme flexibility, and fantastic ease of use. Perfect for virtually any site.Full Wix Review »
Weebly3rd9.7 out of 10Free

Weebly Review

Weebly is an easy-to-use powerful website builder. While not as robust as some options, for most sites, Weebly is sufficient.Full Weebly Review »
SquareSpace4th9.7 out of 10$16.00 Per Month

SquareSpace Review

With its flexibility & amazing responsive designs, Squarespace works great for everybody from designers to bloggers to entrepreneurs and beyond.Full SquareSpace Review »

Yahoo Web Hosting

5th7.3 out of 10$5.99 Per Month

Yahoo Web Hosting Review

A simple web hosting service that is perfect for beginners, thanks to its easy to digest tools, great mobile conversion tool, and more.Full Yahoo Web Hosting Review »

IM Creator

6th8.4 out of 10$9.95 Per Month

IM Creator Review

A creative, purely drag-and-drop website builder that comes with nice templates, but has some limitations in eCommerce and flexibility.Full IM Creator Review »


7th8.4 out of 10Free

Doodlekit Review

Perfect for those on a budget thanks to its free plan, this website builder offers customizable templates, plus tools like SEO, eCommerce and more.Full Doodlekit Review »
WebStarts8th4.5 out of 10$4.89 Per Month

WebStarts Review

There are a lot of lacking features in this web builder, and despite being cheap, you'd really be better off paying a little extra for more functions.Full WebStarts Review »


9th6.2 out of 10$4.16 Per Month

Yola Review

Competitively priced and improving regularly. However, a somewhat slow interface, many outdated themes, and lack of features hold this builder back.Full Yola Review »


10th8.6 out of 10$3.95 Per Month

SiteGround Review

A fantastic web host that also doubles as an affordable website builder where you can build WordPress or Joomla sites, and get 99% uptime.Full SiteGround Review »
Didn't find what you were looking for? Check out these related categories.
Also, here are some important things we looked at for our rankings.

If you're looking for general website builders, check out our roundup of the overall top 10 best website builders.

Important Aspects of Membership Website Builders

Building a website can feel like a challenge, especially if you know very little about coding and web design. Well, there are website builders that cut out these highly technical aspects and give you a less techie process in making your digital space, all with the same professional and functional output. What are the things to keep in mind when looking for a DIY membership website builder? Check them out below!

Content Storage

Since you'll be recruiting members via your website, you might want to provide as much information as you can regarding your organization, its services, and the perks that your visitors can receive as members. Naturally, it follows that an organized content management and publication system within the builder is a must. Some even give you the luxury of setting access for published content - whether for public viewing or members only.

Payment Gateways

Another feature you should look for: payment options for visitors who decide to join and subscribe. While the usual methods are through major credit cards (Visa, MasterCard, American Express, and others), other processors such as PayPal can open the lines for more subscribers. Be sure to check your website builder's supported payment methods.


A unique feature of membership website builders that can really help you keep track of your members is analytics. You can use pertinent data like login and log out times, number of members currently online, new subscribers, unsubscribed count, and website activity to your advantage. Google Analytics integration can deliver this information, but there are builders that offer statistics tracking services in-house.


The last aspect that can definitely make or break your website builder choice is price tag. While the average price ranges from $8 to $10, you can find cheaper alternatives, even a free service with fairly decent offerings. Most paid plans deliver more powerful features though, so you may want to save up for those website builder upgrades.


  • While all of these are website builders that require you to have a subscription membership with them in order to build your website, only the very first “featured” listing (wild apricot) is actually a tool to build a membership website at all.

    Weebly is arguably “kind of” helpful for that as it does have a paid plugin that makes certain pages password protected -but it’s so lacking in features and so annoyingly buggy that it only qualifies as “sorta/kinda” for a membership site – at best. You’re better off connecting sentry login to it with an HTML snippet (that actually works 100x better)…

    Literally NONE of the other builders listed could be even remotely considered a “membership website builder” by any stretch of the imagination (I have used every single one of them).

    On the contrary, these are simply website builders that require a paid membrship for the owner to access all of its features (which do not include the ability to create a membership website).

  • I blog frequently and I genuinely appreciate your information. The article has truly peaked my interest.
    I’m going to book mark your website and keep checking for new information about once
    per week. I opted in for your Feed as well.